Benefit Experts
← All articlesHealth plan funding

Stop-Loss Insurance for Washington Employers: Specific, Aggregate and the Terms That Decide a Bad Year

Every self-funded and level-funded health plan depends on a stop-loss policy. It is the part that turns an open-ended promise to pay claims into a budget with a ceiling. It is also the part employers read least, because it arrives inside a proposal with friendlier pages. This guide explains the two kinds of coverage, the minimums Washington sets and the contract terms that matter in the year things go wrong.

By Benefit Experts · Reviewed by Brandon Hoobler, licensed insurance broker (WA OIC #824207)6 min read
Benefit Experts graphic naming four stop-loss terms Washington employers should check: the specific deductible, the aggregate attachment point, the contract basis and lasers.

The short version

  • Specific stop-loss protects against one very large claimant. Aggregate stop-loss protects against total claims running high.
  • Washington requires an aggregate attachment point of at least 120% of expected claims.
  • The contract basis, such as 12/12 or 12/15, decides whether claims that straddle the plan year are covered.
  • Stop-loss insures the employer, not employees. The plan still owes the claim whether or not the policy reimburses it.

What stop-loss is, and who it protects

Washington law defines stop-loss insurance as "insurance against the risk of economic loss assumed under a self-funded employee disability benefit plan." Source: RCW 48.11.030. In Washington's statutes, "disability" is the term for health coverage.

The policy insures the employer or the plan. It does not insure employees, and by law it pays the plan, not members or providers. Source: RCW 48.21.015. That distinction has a practical consequence: if the stop-loss carrier denies or delays a reimbursement, the plan still owes the medical claim.

Specific and aggregate: two different risks

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners describes the two layers as a specific attachment point "that protects against claim severity" and an aggregate attachment point "that protects against claim frequency." Source: NAIC.

Specific and aggregate: two different risks
Specific (individual)Aggregate
Protects againstOne person with very large claimsTotal claims for the whole group running above expectations
TriggerOne member's claims pass the specific deductibleAll claims for the year pass the aggregate attachment point
Example$50,000 deductible, one member has $180,000 in claims: the employer pays $50,000 and the carrier reimburses $130,000Expected claims of $600,000 with a 125% attachment point of $750,000, actual claims of $800,000: the carrier reimburses $50,000

The two work together. Amounts reimbursed under specific coverage generally do not count again toward the aggregate total, so read how your contract defines the claims that accumulate.

Washington's minimum attachment points

Washington sets a floor under both layers, so a policy cannot be written with attachment points so low that it works like ordinary insurance:

  • Aggregate: at least 120% of expected claims.
  • Specific: not less than 5% of expected claims or $100,000, whichever is less.

Source: RCW 48.21.015. For a group with $400,000 in expected claims, the specific deductible can be no lower than $20,000 and the aggregate attachment point no lower than $480,000. For a group with $3 million in expected claims, the specific floor is $100,000.

The state's filing guidance for carriers adds that a stop-loss policy must include an aggregate attachment point and may or may not include an individual one. Source: Washington OIC filing guidance. The statute itself sets no minimum group size.

Contract basis: which claims count

A stop-loss policy covers claims by two dates: when the service was incurred and when the claim was paid. The contract basis says which combination is covered.

Contract basis: which claims count
BasisCovers claims that areWhat to watch
12/12Incurred and paid within the 12-month policy periodClaims incurred late in the year and paid after it ends are not covered
12/15Incurred in the 12 months and paid within three more monthsAdds run-out protection at the end of the year
15/12Incurred in the three months before the policy period or during it, and paid during itAdds run-in protection for a plan that was already self-funded
PaidPaid during the policy period, whenever incurredCommon at renewal, once a plan is established

Source: Milliman. Source: NAIC. The gap between "incurred" and "paid" matters most twice: in your first self-funded year and in the year you leave. A 12/12 contract in a final year can leave late claims with no stop-loss behind them.

Lasers and other terms that move risk back to you

  • Lasering. The carrier sets "a higher attachment point for one or more individuals with preexisting high cost medical conditions or other identified risk factors." Source: NAIC. If one member is lasered at $250,000 on a plan with a $50,000 specific deductible, the employer carries the extra $200,000 for that person.
  • Aggregating specific deductible. An additional deductible the employer must satisfy across all specific claims before reimbursements begin, usually in exchange for a lower premium.
  • Renewal terms. Ask whether the contract limits new lasers or caps the rate increase at renewal. Where those protections exist, they are written into the policy.
  • Differences from your plan document. A stop-loss policy has its own definitions and exclusions. If the plan pays a claim the policy excludes, the plan pays it alone.

How this works inside a level-funded plan

In a level-funded plan the stop-loss policy is bundled into the fixed monthly payment, so the employer's maximum cost for the year is known in advance. The same terms still apply underneath. The specific deductible, aggregate attachment point, contract basis and renewal provisions are in the proposal, and they decide what happens to a surplus, a shortfall and your final months if you leave.

Our level-funded quote and contract questions walks through that proposal line by line.

Eight questions to ask about any stop-loss quote

  1. What is the specific deductible, and does it apply per person?
  2. What is the aggregate attachment point as a percentage of expected claims, and what is the dollar figure?
  3. What is the contract basis, and what would a run-out provision cost?
  4. Is anyone lasered, at what amount and why?
  5. Does the contract limit new lasers or rate increases at renewal?
  6. Which claims count toward the aggregate: medical only, or prescription drugs too?
  7. How quickly are specific claims reimbursed, and can the carrier advance funds for a large claim?
  8. What happens to claims incurred before termination and paid afterward?

If two quotes differ in price, the answers to these questions usually explain why.

Have the contract read before you sign it

Send Benefit Experts the stop-loss or level-funded proposal you are considering. We will mark the attachment points, contract basis and renewal terms and tell you what each one means for your worst-case year.

Call 206.556.2993 or request a benefits review.

Common employer benefits questions

What is the difference between specific and aggregate stop-loss?

Specific stop-loss reimburses the employer when one covered person's claims pass a set deductible. Aggregate stop-loss reimburses the employer when total claims for the group pass a set attachment point, usually a percentage of expected claims.

What is the minimum aggregate attachment point in Washington?

At least 120% of expected claims. The individual attachment point must be at least 5% of expected claims or $100,000, whichever is less.

What does a 12/15 stop-loss contract mean?

It covers claims incurred during the 12-month policy period and paid during those 12 months or the three months after. The extra three months are run-out protection for claims that arrive late.

What is a laser in stop-loss insurance?

A higher specific deductible applied to a named individual with known high-cost conditions. The employer carries that person's claims up to the higher amount.

Does stop-loss insurance cover employees?

No. It insures the employer or the plan. Employees are covered by the plan itself, which must pay eligible claims whether or not the stop-loss policy reimburses them.

Share this article

Send it to a colleague or save it for your next benefits review.

Follow Benefit Experts on Google

See more of our Washington employer benefits guides in Google Search.

Let’s talk about what fits your business.

Benefit Experts helps Washington employers compare coverage, understand tradeoffs and build a benefits strategy around their people.