Three accounts, three sets of rules.
Section 125 cafeteria plan
The foundation for pre-tax premiums.
A written plan that lets eligible employees pay their portion of group premiums ahead of applicable taxes. A payroll setting marked pre-tax doesn't create one.
- Plan document adopted and current
- Deductions match the document and each employee's election
- Eligibility and permitted midyear election changes written down
- Nondiscrimination testing reviewed where it applies
- Exchange premiums kept out: an employee's share of exchange coverage can't run through it
Health FSA
An annual election employees spend down.
Employees elect an amount by salary reduction, and you can add employer money. For 2026 the salary-reduction limit is $3,400. Unused money is generally forfeited unless the plan adopts a carryover, up to $680 of 2026 money, or a grace period. Dependent care FSAs are a different benefit, governed by different rules.
- Election limit set at or under $3,400 for 2026
- Carryover, grace period or forfeiture decided
- Claim deadline for the prior year's expenses stated
- Limited-purpose version used if the medical plan is HSA-qualified
HSA
Owned by the employee, and only with HSA-qualified coverage.
The employee owns the account, and the balance rolls forward year to year. To contribute, the employee needs HSA-eligible coverage and has to meet the remaining eligibility rules. Money spent on qualified medical costs generally comes out tax-free at the federal level; other withdrawals can be taxed and may draw an additional tax. For 2027 the limits are $4,500 self-only and $9,000 family, with employer and employee money counted together.
- Medical plan confirmed HSA-qualified
- No general-purpose FSA or HRA for anyone contributing
- Employer contribution amount and timing set
- Employees on Medicare flagged, since enrollment affects eligibility
Where HRAs fit
Employer money only.
Employees don't contribute to an HRA, so keep reimbursements apart from salary reductions in payroll. The HRA type decides what it can pay: an ICHRA can reimburse individual premiums, while an integrated HRA or excepted-benefit HRA works beside a group plan. Our HRA decision guide sorts them.
How a premium only plan works.
Three minutes on premium only plans: how pre-tax premiums work, what employees and the business save, which premiums qualify, and the setup rules.
Two conflicts that undo good designs.
The HSA conflict
Give an HSA contributor a general-purpose health FSA or HRA and they can lose the right to contribute. If the medical plan is HSA-qualified, use a premium-only, limited-purpose or post-deductible design for the other account.
The exchange premium trap
An employee buying through Washington Healthplanfinder pays the remaining premium after tax, because Section 125 salary reductions can't touch it, even when an ICHRA reimburses part of the premium.
Match the accounts to the medical plan.
With a copay plan: Section 125 for premiums, a general-purpose health FSA, and an integrated HRA if you want to help with the deductible.
With an HSA-qualified plan: Section 125 for premiums, an HSA, and a limited-purpose or post-deductible FSA or HRA, designed so HSA contributions stay allowed.
With an ICHRA: the HRA reimburses premiums up to the allowance. Any remaining exchange premium is paid after tax, while a remaining off-exchange premium may be payable pre-tax through a compliant cafeteria plan.
Illustrative: a 20-person employer puts $50 a month into each employee's HSA. That's $12,000 a year, and each employee's own contributions plus the employer's $600 count toward the same annual limit.
For a side-by-side of the three accounts, see HSA vs. FSA vs. HRA for Washington employers.
Set it up before the plan year starts.
-
STEP 01
Choose the medical plan first
Whether it's HSA-qualified decides which FSA and HRA designs are allowed.
-
STEP 02
Adopt or update the documents
Section 125 plan, FSA terms and any HRA plan document, all matching what payroll will actually do.
-
STEP 03
Set the limits
FSA elections up to $3,400 for 2026, and a carryover of up to $680 if you allow one. HSA limits for 2027 are $4,500 self-only and $9,000 family.
-
STEP 04
Configure payroll
Deduction codes match elections, and HRA reimbursements stay out of salary reductions.
-
STEP 05
Enroll and explain
Employees elect during open enrollment. We run enrollment in Employee Navigator and offer group, individual and live virtual education at no extra fee for client teams.
-
STEP 06
During the year
Change elections only when the plan permits it, and revisit the design at renewal.
What we need to check your setup.
- Your Section 125 plan document, or a note that you don't have one
- Your payroll provider and current pre-tax deduction codes
- The SBC for each medical plan
- Current FSA, HSA and HRA vendors and terms
- Your plan year and how many employees use an HSA
We'll flag gaps between the documents, the payroll setup and the accounts. Have payroll or your tax adviser confirm the tax treatment before anything changes.
The questions that come up at enrollment.
Our only pre-tax deduction is the medical premium. Do we still need a Section 125 plan?
Yes. Pre-tax treatment for employee premium contributions comes from a written cafeteria plan. A payroll setting alone doesn't establish one.
Can an employee have an HSA and a health FSA?
Only if the FSA is limited-purpose or post-deductible. Either a general-purpose FSA or a general-purpose HRA can block HSA contributions, and other coverage, including Medicare, matters too.
What happens to FSA money left at the end of the year?
It's generally forfeited unless the plan has a carryover or a grace period. With a carryover, up to $680 of unused 2026 money can roll into the next plan year.
Who keeps the HSA when an employee leaves?
The employee. The account belongs to them and the balance carries forward. An HRA is different: it stays an employer reimbursement arrangement, governed by the plan.
Where these rules come from.
Sources: IRS Publication 969, IRS: cafeteria plan FAQs, IRS: 2026 HSA guidance, HealthCare.gov: HRA options and CMS: HRA questions and answers. General information, not legal or tax advice.
Check your pre-tax setup before open enrollment.
Send your plan documents and payroll setup. We'll flag what doesn't line up, with no obligation.