Benefit Experts
What changes

A broker-of-record letter changes who represents you. Nothing else.

  • No change to your plan, carrier or rates
  • No new enrollment for employees
  • No gap in coverage
  • Your new broker can request renewal and plan information from the carrier

A broker-of-record letter is a short, signed letter on company letterhead that names a new broker as your representative with a carrier. The carrier records the change, and from then on the new broker can request renewals, quotes and service on your behalf.

Your plan, your carrier, your rates, your effective dates and your employees’ ID cards all stay the same. Employees usually notice nothing until they need help, and then they reach a different person.

Broker-of-record letters are filed with each carrier, so you can appoint a new broker for one line of coverage, such as dental, and leave another arrangement in place for the rest.

Watch: 5 signs

Is your benefits broker working hard for you?

Last-minute renewals, one option, confused employees, paperwork overload, once-a-year contact. Five signs it may be time for a second opinion, and what good service looks like instead.

How it works

Switching in four steps.

STEP 01

Send what you have

Your current plan summaries, the latest renewal or rates, and an employee census. A short call is enough to start.

STEP 02

Sign the letter

We draft a broker-of-record letter for each carrier. You sign it on company letterhead.

STEP 03

Carrier confirms

We submit the letters and follow each one to confirmation. Some carriers notify the current broker and wait a short period before the change takes effect.

STEP 04

Review and compare

With your renewal in hand, we compare it against the market, including level-funded and HRA options where they fit, and walk you through the choices before your deadline.

Timing

When to switch.

You can change brokers at any time. You are not locked to your renewal date, and the change does not have to wait for open enrollment.

Starting 60 to 90 days before your renewal gives the new broker room to request renewal information, gather a census and quote alternatives before decisions are due. Later still works; there is simply less time to compare.

Watch

Four questions to ask before you renew.

A 43-second checklist for the conversation to have before your renewal is due.

Day to day

What the switch looks like from each side.

For your employees

Same cards, same doctors, same payroll deductions, same carrier phone numbers. What changes is who they call for help with a claim, a form or a question. We send a short note that says exactly that, and if you like, we follow it with a brief meeting.

For you and your HR team

The bill still comes from each carrier and is paid the same way, and your plan year does not move. Renewals, quotes and carrier problems come to us once each carrier confirms. If your current broker supplied your enrollment system, we set you up on Employee Navigator before that access ends.

Timing around renewal

Where you are in the plan year decides what we do first.

Renewal more than 90 days away

Time for a full review.

We gather plan documents, past renewals and a census, then quote the market before your renewal arrives. If a different carrier or a level-funded plan fits, there is time to do it properly.

Renewal 30 to 90 days away

Work from the offer in hand.

We review your renewal, compare it with what can be quoted in time, and get your decision to the carrier before the deadline. A fuller market review can follow next year.

Renewal just signed, or mid-year

Service now, shopping later.

The switch still makes sense. We start with service and clean records, then begin the next market review early.

If you also want to change carriers

Check participation rules first.

Some small groups cannot meet a carrier’s contribution or participation rules. Under federal rules (45 CFR 147.104), the carrier may limit those groups to enrolling from November 15 through December 15 each year. We check this early, because it can decide whether a carrier change is possible at your renewal date.

After you sign

Our first 90 days after a switch.

STEP 01

Confirm every line

We track written confirmation from each carrier, line by line, and tell you where to send questions until every one is in.

STEP 02

Gather the paper trail

Plan documents, benefit summaries, the latest renewal and current bill from each carrier, plus your Section 125 plan document if employees pay premiums pre-tax.

STEP 03

Reconcile the bill

We compare each invoice with your employee list and payroll deductions. Former employees still billed, or new hires missing, get fixed now rather than at renewal.

STEP 04

Write down your rules

One page covering the new hire waiting period, hours to qualify, your contribution by tier and when coverage ends. Carriers, payroll and HR then work from the same version.

STEP 05

Set up enrollment and meet your people

We load your plans and employees into Employee Navigator, train your administrator, and introduce ourselves through a meeting on site or by video.

STEP 06

Set the renewal calendar

By day 90 you have a written timeline for your next renewal, including the date we start reviewing the market.

Before you sign with anyone

Questions to ask any broker, including us.

What will be done by day 90?

Ask for the first-90-days plan in writing. A clear answer before you sign is a good sign.

Will you meet my employees?

Ask how open enrollment and new hires are handled: on-site meetings, one-on-one conversations, video sessions, or just a link and a PDF.

What would you leave alone?

A good review names the parts of your current setup that already work. If everything needs replacing, ask why.

Is anything billed on top?

Ask how the broker is compensated and which services or vendors have separate charges. There is no fee at this time for our agency's services; insurance carriers compensate us through commissions. Third-party administrators may charge their own fees.

What happens to our records if we leave?

Enrollment history, plan documents and employee records should go with you. Ask before you need them.

What do you need from us, and when?

A good broker asks for the census, plan documents and renewal on a clear timeline, so nothing lands on your desk at the last minute.

Common questions

Switching brokers, answered.

Will our employees have to re-enroll?

No. Changing brokers does not change the plan, so there is no new enrollment. Employees keep their coverage and their ID cards.

Do we have to tell our current broker?

It is courteous but not required. The carrier records the change, and some carriers notify the current broker as part of the process.

Can we switch in the middle of the plan year?

Yes. A broker-of-record change does not have to wait for renewal. If you decide to change the plan itself, that usually happens at your renewal date.

Does it cost anything to switch?

We do not charge a fee for our brokerage services; brokers are compensated by the carriers. Some administration services, such as COBRA, are run by third-party administrators that bill their own fees, and we tell you about those before you sign up.

Can we change brokers for just one coverage line?

Usually, yes. Broker-of-record letters are filed with each carrier, so you can appoint a new broker for one line and keep another arrangement for the rest.

Will our rates change because we switched brokers?

A broker-of-record change alone does not replace your policy. Ask the carrier to confirm the change and its effective date; premiums and enrollment remain subject to the existing policy terms. There is no fee at this time for our agency's services. We identify any separate third-party administrator fees before you decide.

Should we tell our employees we changed brokers?

Yes, briefly. They need to know who to call. We draft the note for you: what changed (the contact) and what did not (their plan, card and deductions).

What if we are not happy after switching?

You can change again the same way. A new broker-of-record letter to each carrier names someone else, whether another broker or your previous one.

Get a second opinion before your renewal.

Send your renewal and census. We will tell you plainly whether a change makes sense.